Onion services have been found, so onion routing must be broken.
What happened
Many of the cases on record come down to mistakes made around the service: a server that also answered at a normal internet address, software that printed its real address in an error page, third-party scripts, an operator who reused a personal email address. The cases that were attacks on Tor itself used guard discovery and timing, which the next blocks cover. None of them involved breaking Tor's encryption.
What Aphotic does
Aphotic's server is set up to rule out the configuration mistakes. It has no normal internet address that could leak. It sits on an internal-only network where the Tor process is the one thing that can reach the outside world, and every incoming port is shut. Replies carry no identifying headers, and even the health check gives away no version number. What the server stores is listed field by field on the transparency page.